| Platinum | Gennaro & Son Italian Bistro |
| Gold | Balducci's House of Pizza |
| Silver | 16C Restaurant |
| Silver | Fowler House Cafe |
| Bronze | Old Railroad Cafe |
| Top Pick | I Love Italian Pizza |
| Top Pick | Montilios Adams Street |
| Top Pick | Romanzza Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rosie's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Schoolhouse Pizza |
